Signup for a folk alley account


What Makes an Award-Winning Country Instrumental?

February 18, 2008

This year's winner of the Best Country Instrumental Grammy was Brad Paisley - Hot Country, electric guitar playing Brad Paisley. Jim Blum was not impressed and said so during a special segment he did on the Grammys. A couple of listeners called him on his comments (he said judges might have been asleep to pass up The Time Jumpers, Russ Barenberg, The Greencards, and Andy Statman in favor of Paisley) and said that Paisley, one of the most respected instrumentalists in Country, deserved the honor. Jim's answer was that Paisley had the advantage of name recognition.

While that is most certainly true, I think he was also at a disadvantage because this award generally goes to a bluegrass performance (Since 2000, it's gone to Alison Krauss twice, Earl Scruggs & co. twice and Alison Brown & Bela Fleck. Last year, it went to Bryan Sutton & Doc Watson. In 2002, it went to the Dixie Chicks, which is closer to Hot Country, but they still have bluegrass cred). My opinion? The category is Best Country Instrumental, not best traditional country or best bluegrass. Why shouldn't Paisley be honored for excellence if he is genuinely producing stand-out work? NB, I don't have the album and had to listen to the song as a YouTube video made on someone's cell phone, so it's hard to tell. BTW, whoever writes Paisley's news section does a great job and has his/her own comments on the Grammys. And, you have to take any award with a grain of salt. What do you think?

Posted by Ann VerWiebe at February 18, 2008 1:59 PM


Comments

FUN!

Posted by: John Wm Smith at February 20, 2008 7:47 PM

I think you can almost always make an argument for someone else when awards are handed out. Paisley is good and deserves it. I liked The Greencards for this one, but they will survive not getting it.

BTW, does anyone still think The Greencards are a bluegrass band?

Posted by: Doug Sligh at February 23, 2008 7:03 AM

I think the Greencards instrumental stuff is still surprisingly bluegrass - but it stands out now on the album because the other material not so much.

Posted by: Ann E VerWiebe at February 23, 2008 11:42 AM

I dunno, I mean, like Doug said, you can make a case for just about anyone to win one award or the other, but I have to admit, that is some pretty hot picking, even coming off of a cell phone video. Especially coming off a cell phone video! I think a lot of times the award might end up in the hands of a bluegrass picker because a good bluegrass musician is just so dammed impressive. You may have the prettiest cello/piano/sax/honky tonk/etc line in the world, but if you put it side by side with Ricky Skaggs or Tony Rice or Brian Sutton flying through "Red Haired Boy", it's hard to deny their technical ability and flair.

Nathan


- Check out Berlin's only true Kentucky Bluegrass picker at www.nathankentucky.com! -

Posted by: Nathan Kentucky at February 25, 2008 5:03 AM

There are lots of hot pickers in bluegrass, but I like Kym Warner's ability to show of his virtuosity when not heating up the strings. He has perfect timing and can make the mandolin a truly beautiful instrument. I agree with Ann that they are still able to evoke bluegrass history when they play, but this is an evolving trio and they are almost a jazz band at times.

Posted by: Doug Sligh at February 25, 2008 7:46 AM

I'm a big admirer of Brad Paisley as a complete performer and a songwriter. My favorite instrumentation is what serves the song, not what showcases the pyrotechnics, so what works to my ear has much more to do with texture than with virtuosity. Paisley's playing serves the song, better than most session players' contributions can. The bluegrass players who burn a lot of rubber on their solos are impressive, they are hot, they are imitated, but they never take a good song in the direction I'd like it taken in. So which kind makes for a better record, and which kind should be singled out? I've got no heartburn with this award decision.

Posted by: Joan Kennedy at March 26, 2008 4:34 PM

Hoo-kay, I hadn't seen the video, I guess Brad can burn the rubber too. Which I guess points up the restraint he uses when he plays to support his vocals, though that's apparently not what got him the award.

Posted by: Joan Kennedy at March 26, 2008 10:46 PM

Registered users can post comments in the blog. Please register or log in to share your views.

Support Folk Alley During Our Spring Fund Drive!

 

Recent Topics

 

 

October 2014
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
         1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31   


October 2014


September 2014


August 2014


July 2014


June 2014


April 2014


March 2014


February 2014


January 2014


December 2013


November 2013


October 2013


September 2013


August 2013


July 2013


June 2013


May 2013


April 2013


March 2013


February 2013


December 2012


November 2012


October 2012


September 2012


August 2012


July 2012


June 2012


May 2012


April 2012


March 2012


February 2012


January 2012


December 2011


November 2011


October 2011


September 2011


August 2011


July 2011


June 2011


May 2011


April 2011


March 2011


February 2011


January 2011


December 2010


November 2010


October 2010


September 2010


August 2010


July 2010


May 2010


April 2010


March 2010


February 2010


January 2010


December 2009


November 2009


October 2009


September 2009


August 2009


July 2009


June 2009


May 2009


April 2009


March 2009


February 2009


January 2009


December 2008


November 2008


October 2008


September 2008


August 2008


July 2008


June 2008


May 2008


April 2008


March 2008


February 2008


January 2008


December 2007


November 2007


October 2007


September 2007


August 2007


July 2007


June 2007


May 2007


April 2007


March 2007


February 2007


January 2007


December 2006


November 2006


October 2006


September 2006


August 2006


July 2006


June 2006


May 2006


April 2006


March 2006


February 2006


January 2006


December 2005


November 2005


October 2005


September 2005


August 2005


July 2005


June 2005


May 2005


April 2005


March 2005


February 2005


January 2005


December 2004


November 2004


October 2004


September 2004


August 2004


July 2004


June 2004


May 2004


April 2004


March 2004


February 2004


January 2004


December 2003


November 2003


October 2003


September 2003


August 2003